These cream jam tarts are almost too pretty to eat…almost. The combination of the buttery tart shells, cream cheese-spiked cream, & tart jam is to die for!

3 Cream Jam Tarts on a little plate

Looking for a refreshing, show stopper of a dessert? You came to the right place, friend. These miniature cream jam tarts are the perfect mouthful of fresh cream, tangy jam, and buttery pastry shell. Great for parties and special occasions! 

Homemade Pastry for Jam Tarts

For this recipe, you’ll have to make your own homemade pastry for the jam tarts. Similar to puff pastry, it’s flakey and buttery. Find a high-level overview of the ingredients for the pasty and the purpose they serve here. 

  • Cold Unsalted Butter – You’ll want the butter to be cold because you are going to grate it. This helps create a flakiness! 
  • All-Purpose Flour – Classic all-purpose, plain flour is all you need to build the dough. 
  • Sugar – A little sweetness in the tart prevents it from tasting bland. 
  • Egg Yolks – Egg yolks help bind everything together and gives the tarts a nice, golden coloring. 
  • Crisco Shortening – Shortening also helps bring a flakey texture to the dough. 
  • Iced Water – Ice cold water is key to making this pastry dough because it keeps the butter and shortening from melting.

Do you need a tart pan to make these? No! You can use a regular, old mini muffin tin just fine. 

Whipping Up Our Simple Cream Jam Tarts

Aside from making the homemade dough, these cream jam tarts require you to make a delicious fresh cream.

  • Make the Pastry Dough. First, combine the flour with the sugar and grate the cold butter into the mixture. Next, stir in the egg yolks and shortening, followed by the ice cold water. Work the dough by hand until it’s well-combined and let dough chill in the fridge for 30 minutes.
  • Make the Tart Shells: Next, roll the dough out thin on a well-floured work surface and cut out the shells with a flower-shaped cookie cutter. Place a dough piece inside each mini cupcake pan mold. Bake the tart shells in the oven at 350°F for about 15 minutes or until the crust turns golden brown.
  • Make the Jello Filling: Combine the Jello mix with hot water and allow it to cool to room temperature. Beat the cream cheese with a mixer until it’s fluffy and stir in the TruWhip or Cool Whip. Finally, add in the cooled Jello and whisk until combined.
  • Assemble the Cream Jam Tarts: Spoon a couple teaspoons of jam into each cooled tart shell. Stuff the Jello cream filling into a piping bag and pipe it into the tart shells. Enjoy!

A Couple of Key Tips

A couple of handy tips will help you knock these cream jam tarts way out of the park. 

  • Allow the tart shells to cool completely before filling them. You’ll want to work with tart shells that are completely cooled to room temperature so they don’t melt the delicate cream filling. 
  • Swap in your favorite jam or preserves. We love using strawberry, apricot, or raspberry jam, but feel free to swap in whichever kind you like best. Orange marmalade, lemon curd, and plum jam are all great options. 
  • Give the tarts time to set in the fridge before you serve them. To help the tarts keep their shape and develop their flavors, give them 30 minutes to set in the fridge before serving them.    

Hot Tip: Switch things up by using different jello flavors. I love using lemon flavor, but my sister prefers berry flavors. You can’t go wrong!

Storing Cream Jam Tarts

To keep cream jam tarts on hand for up to five days, store them in an airtight container in the fridge. Be extra careful when you remove the container around so they don’t tip over and lose their shape! 

FAQ

Can you make jam tarts with store bought puff pastry?

In a pinch, you can make these jam tarts with store bought puff pastry. To do so, make sure you roll the puff pastry out super thin before taking the stencil to the dough.

Can jam tarts be frozen?

While you can freeze the cooked tart shells, it’s not a good idea to freeze the fully assembled cream jam tarts. The cream doesn’t thaw well at all and they will lose their light fluffiness. To freeze the tart shells solo, assemble them in a single layer on a baking sheet lined with parchment paper. Pop the sheet in the fridge uncovered until the shells are completely frozen and transfer them to a freezer safe bag.

What size cutter should you use for jam tarts?

For best results, use a 2-inch flower-shaped cookie cutter to make the tart shells for these cream jam tarts.

What size piping tip should you use to pipe the cream for jam tarts?

This drop flower tip 109 by Wilton is best for piping the cream into jam tarts. It creates a really nice flower effect, while also creating a nice volume to the cream.

More Simple Desserts to Try

About Author

Natalya Drozhzhin

Natalya founded Momsdish to demonstrate that placing a homemade meal on the table is not hard at all. Natalya makes cooking easier and approachable, by simplifying the ingredients, while still producing the same great taste.